The Hidden Cost Of Loyalty: How Staying With The Same Bank Or Insurance Company Could Be Draining Your Wallet

The Hidden Cost Of Loyalty: How Staying With The Same Bank Or Insurance Company Could Be Draining Your Wallet


June 5, 2025 | Miles Brucker

The Hidden Cost Of Loyalty: How Staying With The Same Bank Or Insurance Company Could Be Draining Your Wallet


It’s easy to assume that staying loyal to your bank or insurance provider means you’ll be rewarded for your consistency. After all, long-term relationships should come with perks, right? In reality, many institutions count on customer inertia and quietly raise rates or reduce benefits for long-time clients who aren’t actively shopping around.

Rate Increases For The Loyal

Insurance companies, in particular, have been found to use a practice known as “price optimization.” This involves raising rates on customers who are unlikely to switch providers. Instead of rewarding loyalty, they penalize it. You might assume your rates are rising due to market conditions, but in many cases, it’s your loyalty that’s being monetized.

Woman, documents and reading on sofa checking billsHockleyMedia, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Banks Don’t Offer The Best To Old Customers

Banks often entice new customers with attractive offers—high-interest savings accounts, low-fee checking, or generous sign-up bonuses. Long-term customers rarely get these deals unless they actively ask for them or threaten to leave. Your savings account might be earning a fraction of what newer customers are offered simply because you haven’t checked in years.

Introductory Offers Expire Quietly

One of the biggest traps comes in the form of expiring introductory rates. Whether it's a promotional credit card APR or a temporary insurance discount, the special terms you started with don’t last. If you’re not paying close attention, you may find yourself paying significantly more after the promotional period ends—with little to no warning.

Loyalty Fees In Disguise

Some banks and insurance companies impose so-called “loyalty fees” through complex pricing structures. These aren't labeled as such, but they show up in higher premiums, reduced yields, or added administrative costs. They count on the idea that long-time customers won’t question or compare their bills to others in the market.

Serious elderly husband and wife review utility billsberdiyandriy, Shutterstock

Advertisement

You’re Less Likely To Shop Around

Behavioral economists have long noted that people tend to stick with what’s familiar, even when better alternatives exist. This “status quo bias” benefits banks and insurers. They assume (often correctly) that loyal customers won’t take the time to comparison shop or switch providers, even if they could save hundreds of dollars.

Bundling Isn’t Always A Bargain

While bundling your home and auto insurance or multiple financial products under one institution may seem convenient, it’s not always cost-effective. Providers often use bundling to obscure individual pricing, which can make it harder to determine if you’re actually getting a good deal. Sometimes, separate providers offer better individual rates.

Loyalty Can Limit Innovation

Sticking with the same financial provider may also mean missing out on new, innovative services. Fintech startups and digital-first insurers are offering better user experiences, lower fees, and faster customer service. But if you’ve been with the same traditional institution for decades, you might not be aware of these emerging options.

Negotiate Lower Interest RatesAndrea Piacquadio, Pexels

Advertisement

No Negotiation Without Pressure

Long-time customers often get the worst deals because providers assume they won’t negotiate. But once you show signs of leaving—like requesting a quote or closing an account—many institutions suddenly find ways to lower your rate or waive a fee. This proves they had room to improve your deal all along.

How To Break The Cycle

Review your accounts and policies annually. Compare your current bank’s savings and checking rates to national averages and competitors. Get quotes from at least three insurance companies before your annual renewal. The process takes a little time, but the savings can be substantial—and ongoing.

Consider Credit Unions And Online Banks

Don’t limit yourself to traditional banks or giant insurance firms. Credit unions and online-only banks often offer significantly better interest rates and lower fees. Similarly, niche or regional insurance providers may offer better service and pricing than the major players who dominate the market through advertising.

Satisfied man at workG-Stock Studio, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Loyalty Doesn’t Mean Complacency

You don’t need to be disloyal to be smart. If you like your bank or insurer, use competitive offers as leverage. Ask if they’ll match or beat a competitor’s rate. Some will appreciate the heads-up and act to keep you as a client. Others won’t—and in that case, walking away may be your best financial move.

Shop Around And Speak Up

The financial world quietly punishes loyalty more often than it rewards it. Staying too long with a provider out of habit can cost you hundreds—or even thousands—over time. To protect your wallet, treat your financial relationships the same way you treat any contract: up for renewal and open to negotiation.

You May Also Like:

Warren Buffett's Best Middle-Class Money Advice

16 Things Baby Boomers Shouldn’t Waste Money On

Finance Tips For Couples

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4


READ MORE

My boss found my modeling website and told me to delete it or lose my job. Is that even legal?

So, your boss found your OnlyFans—and now you're facing a serious ultimatum: delete your account or lose your job. This situation raises complex questions about privacy, legality, and your rights as an employee.
July 25, 2025 Jesse Singer

My ex put me on his health insurance. Now he wants me to pay half the premium even though we’ve broken up. Am I legally obligated?

After a breakup, one partner may remain on the other’s health insurance. If your ex is asking you to pay half the premium, are you legally obligated? This common situation raises questions about financial responsibility, enforceability, and boundaries. Let’s explore the legal facts, practical steps, and key points you need to consider moving forward.
July 18, 2025 Jack Hawkins
intro

We used our entire emergency fund after my wife's accident, and I'm scared something else could happen. What do I do?

That safety net you worked so hard to build just disappeared. The reason doesn't matter right now. What really matters is having a game plan to get back on solid ground quickly.
July 14, 2025 Miles Brucker
professional

Ranking The Top Cities For Young Professionals—According To Data

We looked at job growth, average salaries, major industries, and lifestyle perks to rank the best US cities for young professionals.
July 25, 2025 Allison Robertson

I listened to a finance guru on TV and bought stocks that just bottomed out. I've lost everything. How do I rebuild?

While investing is a key part of retirement savings, we understand it can come with a degree of risk. Whether you're investing via dollar-cost averaging over a long period, or have chucked a bunch of money into the stock market from a severance pay, inheritance, or divorce settlement, don't get caught up in the "financial gurus" who preach buying single stocks. Here's what to do if you've overinvested and lost it all.
July 16, 2025 Jack Hawkins


Disclaimer

The information on MoneyMade.com is intended to support financial literacy and should not be considered tax or legal advice. It is not meant to serve as a forecast, research report, or investment recommendation, nor should it be taken as an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or adopt any particular investment strategy. All financial, tax, and legal decisions should be made with the help of a qualified professional. We do not guarantee the accuracy, timeliness, or outcomes associated with the use of this content.





Dear reader,


It’s true what they say: money makes the world go round. In order to succeed in this life, you need to have a good grasp of key financial concepts. That’s where Moneymade comes in. Our mission is to provide you with the best financial advice and information to help you navigate this ever-changing world. Sometimes, generating wealth just requires common sense. Don’t max out your credit card if you can’t afford the interest payments. Don’t overspend on Christmas shopping. When ordering gifts on Amazon, make sure you factor in taxes and shipping costs. If you need a new car, consider a model that’s easy to repair instead of an expensive BMW or Mercedes. Sometimes you dream vacation to Hawaii or the Bahamas just isn’t in the budget, but there may be more affordable all-inclusive hotels if you know where to look.


Looking for a new home? Make sure you get a mortgage rate that works for you. That means understanding the difference between fixed and variable interest rates. Whether you’re looking to learn how to make money, save money, or invest your money, our well-researched and insightful content will set you on the path to financial success. Passionate about mortgage rates, real estate, investing, saving, or anything money-related? Looking to learn how to generate wealth? Improve your life today with Moneymade. If you have any feedback for the MoneyMade team, please reach out to [email protected]. Thanks for your help!


Warmest regards,

The Moneymade team