A Surprising Refusal
You finally had the budget to offer your best part-time worker a full-time position with better pay and benefits. Instead of excitement, you were met with hesitation and ultimately a “no.” It seems baffling at first glance, but her refusal is rooted in a very real problem known as the "benefits cliff."
Understand The Benefits Cliff
The benefits cliff describes the point where even a small increase in income triggers a sudden loss of essential benefits like SNAP or Medicaid. For a lot of low-income workers, the value of these benefits far outweighs whatever raise you may offer them. Without a gradual phase-out, taking an offer for a better job can actually make them poorer in the short term.
SNAP Loss Hurts More Than You Realize
SNAP (Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program) benefits AKA "food stamps" can cover hundreds of dollars in groceries each month. Losing that support isn’t just a minor inconvenience, but is financially devastating. In most instances, a $2–3 dollar-an-hour raise can’t compensate for the sudden gap in income. When your employee ran the numbers, she most likely realized that accepting the offer would cause her to have a monthly deficit.
Health Insurance Makes The Decision Harder
If your part-time worker is also receiving Medicaid, losing it can be an even more frightening prospect. Private insurance premiums and deductibles can far surpass the value of a raise. Even with your company’s benefits, the transition can be unaffordable. From her point of view, turning down your offer may have been the only way to stay afloat.
Summit Art Creations, Shutterstock
It’s Not Lack of Ambition, But A Matter Of Survival
It’s easy to assume that employees who turn down full-time work lack drive and ambition. But most are acting rationally out of necessity, not complacency. The system is set up in a way that rewards staying below certain income thresholds. She may want to grow, but in the here-and-now the math just doesn’t allow room to take the risk.
Have An Honest Conversation
If you really want to hire this person, your next step is to talk openly. Tell her you value her work and want to understand her concerns without judgment. Ask what specific benefits she’s at risk of losing and what income level will trigger the cutoff. Sometimes, the barrier is smaller than you think. If you take that into consideration and explore it with the employee, it can build trust between the two of you.
Run The Numbers Together
Sit down and calculate her potential earnings with the raise versus the loss of support. You might find a creative solution of some kind once you can see the whole picture laid out. This also reassures her that you’re not trying to push her into a financial setback that she can’t recover from.
Consider Fine-Tuning The Offer
Again, depending on how much you want to increase the employee’s role, examine the feasibility of restructuring the offer to soften the financial impact. This could include higher starting pay, a gradual increase in hours, additional stipends, or hiring bonuses. Some employers even offer grocery or transportation assistance as temporary supplements during the transition off SNAP benefits.
Look At Whether She Qualified for Partial Benefits
In some states, SNAP benefits taper off gradually instead of stopping abruptly. She may still qualify for partial assistance under certain conditions. Encourage her to contact a caseworker or local benefits office to get to the bottom of the exact thresholds, instead of relying on assumptions or outdated information.
Check For Medicaid Expansion Options
If the employee is worried about Medicaid loss, investigate your state’s expansion rules. Some states offer transitional medical coverage for people moving from public insurance to employer plans. If she didn’t know about these programs, this knowledge could change her perspective considerably.
Review Your Company’s Benefits Package
Your health coverage, retirement plan, or child-care benefits might offset the loss of SNAP more than she realized. Share the full value of your benefits, including employer contributions, insurance subsidies, and tax advantages, so she can see the complete picture, not just the paycheck.
Offer Gradual Increases In Hours
If jumping from part-time to full-time would push her over the income threshold, consider raising her hours more slowly. This allows her to monitor how the changes affect her benefits while lowering the risk of a sudden unpleasant financial shock. It also gives both of you the flexibility to adjust things as you go.
Create A Long-Term Growth Plan
If she isn’t ready now, ask what conditions would make the promotion possible in the future. A written plan with milestones, skills development, or performance-based raises could show her you’re invested in her long-term success and not just trying to fill a role quickly.
Look Into State Work Incentive Programs
Some states offer incentives for workers trying to transition off public benefits, including temporary financial assistance, reduced insurance premiums, or employment coaching. If she qualifies, these programs could help soften the financial impact of losing SNAP or Medicaid during her transition.
You May Need To Restructure Your Hiring Approach
If you encounter multiple employees facing this same issue, it could be time to rethink your staffing model. Consider whether certain roles truly need full-time workers or whether you can create hybrid positions that provide stability without bringing about benefit losses.
Don’t Take It Personally
It may feel like she doesn’t appreciate the offer or doesn’t have the ambition that it takes to move up. In reality, her fear of losing essential support is perfectly understandable. Keeping emotions out of the situation helps you stay focused on solutions instead of tearing your hair out in frustration.
Recognize That This Is a Systemic Issue
What you’re experiencing is not unique. Businesses across the country struggle with the tension between offering advancement and navigating benefits cliffs. Understanding the systemic nature of the problem helps you frame the situation as an economic challenge—not a personal failure.
Document Your Efforts For Internal Planning
Record the conversation, the compensation structure, and the reasons why she declined. This helps you adjust your approach for future hiring, ensures transparency, and provides a clear reference if the same kind of issues arise with other employees.
Continue Supporting Her Growth
Even if she can’t accept full-time work now, provide training, flexible scheduling, and opportunities that improve her long-term outlook. Show commitment beyond the immediate promotion, and you’ll build loyalty that could help her transition when her financial circumstances change.
You Can’t Fix The System Alone, But You Can Help
You can’t control SNAP rules or Medicaid cutoffs, but you can certainly support your employee by getting to understand her situation, offering flexibility, and exploring creative compensation approaches. When you work with her, and not against her, you build trust, hold on to a great worker, and set the stage for a future where she gets around to saying yes.
You May Also Like:
My friends just got back from a luxury cruise, but are asking to borrow money. What now?
