My Brother Thinks I'm Stealing From The Family
You agreed to handle a loved one's estate, and now you're drowning in paperwork, unpaid bills, and endless phone calls. Months have passed, the work keeps piling up, and your brother is furious that you're considering paying yourself. He calls it greedy, but you're the one doing all the work while he waits for his inheritance.
So, are you really taking money from your family, or are you entitled to compensation for a job nobody else wanted?
Your Brother Sees Things Very Differently
From your brother's perspective, every dollar you receive is potentially one less dollar for the beneficiaries. But you're the one dealing with creditors, financial institutions, and legal responsibilities. That difference in perspective can turn an already emotional inheritance into a bitter family dispute.
Being Executor Is An Actual Job
An executor is legally responsible for administering a deceased person's estate. That includes gathering assets, settling debts, handling tax obligations, and distributing property according to the will and applicable law. These responsibilities don't disappear simply because the executor happens to be a family member.
And The Work Can Take Months
Some estates can be settled relatively quickly, while others take a year or longer. Missing documents, property sales, tax complications, and disputes between beneficiaries can all create delays. If you've been handling estate business for months, that doesn't necessarily mean you're doing anything wrong.
So Can You Actually Pay Yourself?
Here's something your brother might not realize: executors are generally entitled to compensation under U.S. state law, even when they're related to the deceased. The American Bar Association specifically recognizes that estate administration can be difficult and time-consuming. Whether you can collect a fee, and how much, depends on the will and applicable state law.
But The Will Could Change Everything
Before calculating any compensation, check what the deceased person's will actually says. It might establish a specific fee, provide a compensation formula, or contain provisions affecting payment. Those instructions can influence what you're entitled to receive, although state law determines whether they're enforceable.
What If The Will Doesn't Mention Payment?
A silent will doesn't necessarily mean you're expected to work for free. Many states establish executor compensation through statutory formulas or reasonable-fee rules. The important thing is to determine which system applies before assuming you can charge whatever seems fair.
There's No Universal Executor Fee
You may have heard that executors automatically receive a fixed percentage of an estate. That's not how compensation works nationwide, because different states use different approaches. Some establish percentage schedules, while others evaluate the nature and difficulty of the work.
https://kaboompics.com/, Pexels
California Has A Surprisingly Generous Formula
California generally allows ordinary executor compensation of 4% on the first $100,000 of the qualifying estate value, 3% on the next $100,000, and 2% on the next $800,000. The percentages decrease for larger estates. Unlike an ordinary hourly wage, this compensation is calculated using a statutory formula.
A $500,000 Estate Could Mean A $13,000 Fee
Suppose you're administering a California probate estate with a qualifying compensation base of $500,000. The ordinary statutory executor fee would be $13,000, even without calculating every hour worked. California generally bases that calculation on the estate value accounted for during probate, without simply subtracting outstanding debts.
New York Calculates Things Differently
New York generally allows executor commissions of 5% on the first $100,000, 4% on the next $200,000, and 3% on the next $700,000 of qualifying amounts. Commissions are calculated under rules governing money and property received and paid out, with exclusions for certain assets. That means the estate's headline value isn't necessarily the amount used to calculate compensation.
Other States Consider What's Reasonable
In states using reasonable-compensation standards, several factors may influence the fee. These can include the estate's size, the time required, the complexity of administration, and the executor's responsibilities. Managing a difficult estate may justify more compensation than handling one with relatively few complications.
Your Hours Can Help Make Your Case
If you're spending evenings and weekends dealing with estate business, start keeping a detailed record. Note legitimate administrative tasks, including organizing documents, contacting banks, and meeting with professionals. Even where compensation isn't calculated hourly, those records can help explain the work involved and support requests that require evidence of your services.
But More Months Don't Always Mean More Money
Spending a year administering an estate doesn't automatically entitle you to a bigger fee than someone who finishes in six months. States with statutory percentage formulas generally calculate ordinary compensation using qualifying estate values rather than hours worked. Extra payment may be possible for extraordinary services, but that requires following additional rules.
You're Also Taking On Serious Legal Risks
Executors have fiduciary duties, meaning they must manage estate affairs for the benefit of the people legally entitled to the assets. Mishandling property, improperly distributing money, or neglecting certain financial obligations can expose an executor to personal liability. Your responsibility extends far beyond simply passing out inheritance checks.
And The Estate's Debts Come First
Before distributing inheritances, executors must properly address estate debts, expenses, and applicable taxes. That can involve reviewing creditor claims, maintaining property, and making sure sufficient funds remain to cover outstanding obligations. Paying beneficiaries prematurely can create financial and legal problems if unpaid liabilities surface later.
Don't Confuse Expenses With Compensation
Here's an important distinction: an executor's fee and reimbursement for estate expenses aren't the same thing. You may be entitled to reimbursement for reasonable, necessary expenses properly incurred while administering the estate, separate from payment for your services. Keep receipts and accurate records so legitimate estate costs aren't confused with personal purchases.
https://kaboompics.com/, Pexels
You Don't Have To Do Everything Yourself
Some estates require professional help from attorneys, accountants, appraisers, or real estate agents. Executors can generally arrange appropriate assistance and pay reasonable professional expenses from estate funds. However, hiring experts doesn't eliminate your responsibility to oversee the process and protect estate assets.
Some Difficult Jobs Can Earn Extra Compensation
California permits courts to award additional compensation for extraordinary executor services. Examples can include certain real estate transactions, operating a deceased person's business, preparing tax returns, and handling tax-related litigation. These payments aren't automatic, and the court decides whether extra compensation is justified.
But You Can't Just Write Yourself A Check
Even when you're legally entitled to payment, taking money without following the proper procedure can cause trouble. California, for example, generally prohibits executors from receiving compensation before a court order authorizes it. Before transferring estate funds into your own account, confirm the applicable approval requirements.
Does Your Brother Actually Get A Say?
Your brother may have the right to question your compensation, particularly if he believes the amount is excessive or improperly calculated. But his personal disapproval doesn't automatically prevent you from receiving a lawful fee. If the disagreement cannot be resolved, a probate court may need to review the compensation or related accounting.
There's Another Catch: Executor Fees Are Taxable
Under federal tax rules, executor compensation is generally taxable income. The IRS says someone who isn't professionally engaged in executor work typically reports those fees as other income, while professional executors generally report them as business income. That means the amount you actually keep after taxes could be considerably less than the fee you receive.
But An Inheritance Is Different
Property received as an inheritance is generally excluded from federal taxable income, although certain inherited amounts and subsequent earnings can be taxable. Executor fees, on the other hand, are compensation for services and must generally be reported as income. If you're both an executor and a beneficiary, this distinction could influence whether accepting a fee makes financial sense.
Your Brother Has Something To Lose
Executor compensation generally comes from estate funds, reducing the amount potentially available for beneficiaries. If you and your brother are inheriting equal shares of the remaining estate, your fee could reduce both inheritances. His financial concern is understandable, even if that doesn't justify accusing you of wrongdoing.
Transparency Could Save Your Relationship
Rather than announcing a fee without explanation, give your brother a clear picture of the administration process. Share an appropriate summary of the responsibilities you've handled, the expenses incurred, and the legal rules governing compensation. Keeping beneficiaries reasonably informed can reduce suspicion and make disagreements easier to resolve.
What If He Still Calls You Greedy?
Your brother doesn't have to like the idea of executor compensation, but that doesn't determine whether you're entitled to it. You can explain that the fee is governed by legal rules rather than simply being money you've decided to take. If the disagreement escalates, getting independent legal guidance is safer than allowing a family argument to dictate estate decisions.
You Could Choose To Work For Free
Some executors voluntarily waive compensation, particularly when they're already receiving a substantial inheritance. That's a personal choice rather than a universal obligation imposed on family members. Before giving up a potentially significant fee, consult an estate attorney about the consequences and whether the decision can be reversed.
So When Is Taking Payment Actually Reasonable?
Accepting an executor's fee is reasonable when the compensation is legally permitted, properly calculated, and obtained through the required procedures. Months of work and substantial responsibilities can make payment entirely appropriate, although the amount must follow the applicable rules. Being related to the deceased doesn't automatically mean your time and effort have no financial value.
Here's What You Should Do Next
Start by reviewing the will, researching your state's compensation rules, and organizing records of your estate-related work. Before accepting payment, have an estate attorney confirm the amount, tax considerations, and any required court approval. Your brother may think family should work for free, but fair compensation isn't greed when you've followed the rules and earned it.
You May Also Like:
My mother left me more because I handled her care, but my siblings say that’s unfair. Who is right?
Common Financial Advice From The 1980s That Will Almost Definitely Backfire In Today’s Economy
