Yesterday’s Treasure, Today’s Yard Sale Item
Not all collectibles stand the test of time. Some items that once fetched big bucks have crashed in value—leaving collectors puzzled or stuck. Here are 25 once-beloved collector’s items that have lost their shine and now sell for pennies.
Hard Rock Café Pins (Non-Rare)
Estimated value: $30
Once a must-grab souvenir, Hard Rock pins are everywhere. Without a rare or error pin, most barely break even on resale sites.
Thank You (23 Millions+) views, Wikimedia Commons
Star Wars Prequel Toys
Estimated value: $30
Though Star Wars toys are collectible, most toys from the prequel era were mass-produced. Only sealed or rare variants hold decent value.
Common Comic Books (Post-1990)
Estimated value: $28
Comic book collecting lives on—but common issues from the 1990s are rarely valuable due to overprinting during the collector boom.
AlejandroLinaresGarcia, Wikimedia Commons
Frankoma Pottery
Estimated value: $25
These Oklahoma-based ceramic pieces were once popular. But collector interest has waned, and only the rarest now sell for more than a few dollars.
Mad Mod Smith, Wikimedia Commons
State Quarters
Estimated value: $22
Many thought collecting all 50 state quarters would pay off. But since millions were made, a full set is still only worth about face value.
United States Mint, Wikimedia Commons
Modern Barbie Dolls (Non-Limited)
Estimated value: $20
Barbie is iconic, but only early or ultra-limited editions fetch serious money. Most dolls made post-1990s are still worth their original retail price—or less.
Danbury Mint Sports Memorabilia
Estimated value: $20
While some rare sports items do well, mass-produced Mint pieces have flooded the market and lost value quickly.
Collector Thimbles
Estimated value: $18
Thimble collecting was once a legitimate hobby, especially among travelers. Today, boxes of them go for pennies at estate sales.
Finder, Amy Downes, 2007-12-13 12:32:32, Wikimedia Commons
Vintage Cookbooks (Common)
Estimated value: $15
Unless signed or rare, most old cookbooks don’t hold much value. Digital recipes and changing food trends haven’t helped.
Norman Rockwell Figurines
Estimated value: $15
Once beloved for their sentimental scenes, these figurines have lost their collector base. Even mint condition pieces often sit unsold.
Bain News Service, publisher, Wikimedia Commons
Madame Alexander Dolls
Estimated value: $12
These collectible dolls were once displayed with pride. Now, unless you have a rare edition, they’re a hard sell in today’s market.
Royal Doulton Figurines (Common)
Estimated value: $12
These dainty porcelain figures once held charm and value, but younger generations aren’t interested, and the resale value has plummeted.
Vintage Tupperware (Non-Rare)
Estimated value: $10
Some rare Tupperware is valuable, but the bulk of colorful plastic containers are now common and cheap.
Pogs and Slammers
Estimated value: $10
This '90s playground craze came and went. Despite nostalgia, the market has collapsed. Even full sets barely bring in anything.
Department Store Christmas Bears
Estimated value: $10
Once part of annual holiday releases, these branded teddy bears were cute gifts but now fill thrift store shelves.
Collector VHS Tapes (Common Titles)
Estimated value: $8
Some horror VHS tapes fetch money—but most titles, especially blockbusters, are nearly worthless due to mass production.
Olga Berrios from Madrid, España, Wikimedia Commons
Modern Commemorative Coins
Estimated value: $7
While old coins can be valuable, many modern commemorative coins, especially those from TV ads, hold no real numismatic value.
Ty Teenie Beanie Babies
Estimated value: $6
Even less valuable than regular Beanies, these McDonald’s promotions were everywhere in the late '90s. Now they’re barely worth their packaging.
Boyds Bears
Estimated value: $6
Stuffed bears with stories and names, Boyds Bears briefly captivated collectors. But after a market boom in the early 2000s, their resale value tanked.
Avon Bottles
Estimated value: $5
Avon’s novelty perfume bottles were big in the mid-20th century, but mass production and limited collector interest means they now collect dust instead of cash.
Collector Plates (Non-Rare)
Estimated value: $5
From wildlife to Christmas scenes, decorative plates were hot in the '70s–'90s. But lack of demand and sheer volume of them has made most near-valueless.
Longaberger Baskets
Estimated value: $3
Handmade and once costly, Longaberger baskets were a status symbol in home décor. The company’s closure and waning interest have crashed prices.
Franklin Mint Collectibles
Estimated value: $2
High hopes met low resale value. Though heavily marketed as investment pieces, mass production made most Franklin Mint coins and plates nearly worthless today.
Precious Moments Figurines
Estimated value: $1
Sentimental and once gifted often, these porcelain figures flooded the market. Aside from a few rare ones, most are now tough to sell and barely fetch a buck.
Beanie Babies
Estimated value: $0.50
Once the crown jewel of '90s collections, Beanie Babies were predicted to make people rich. But overproduction and false hype led to a market crash. Most are now worth under a dollar.
You May Also Like:
Grandma’s China Might Be Worth More Than You Think
Retro Kitchen Appliances That Are Now Worth Money
Old Advertising Signs That Can Sell for Thousands
