What To Do?
You’ve inherited $200K—amazing, but now the pressure’s on. Do you toss it at your mortgage, or bulk up your retirement? At 58, there’s no time to waste, and the wrong move could cost you peace of mind later.
Start With Your Retirement Reality
How’s your retirement savings looking right now? If you’re behind, this might be the time to catch up. You’re less than a decade from retirement age, and compound growth needs time. If your 401(k) or IRA balance makes you nervous, that $200K could be the boost you need to feel secure.
Check Your Mortgage Details
What’s your interest rate? How many years are left? If you’re paying a high rate or have 10+ years left, paying it off could save you a ton in interest. But if your rate is low and you’re near the end, it may not be the best use of the money.
Think About Monthly Cash Flow
Paying off your mortgage now could free up hundreds—or even thousands—each month. That’s money you could redirect into retirement accounts, savings, or just to breathe easier. If cash flow is tight, clearing that debt could give you major monthly relief heading into retirement.
Consider the Emotional Side
Some people love the idea of being debt-free—it helps them sleep at night. Others would rather see their money grow in investments. This is personal. If being mortgage-free gives you peace of mind and less financial anxiety, that’s worth factoring in, too.
What’s the Tax Picture?
Mortgage interest may still give you a tax deduction (though fewer people itemize now). On the flip side, contributions to retirement accounts like a traditional IRA or 401(k) might lower your taxable income. Talk to a tax pro—it could help you keep more of that $200K.
PeopleImages.com, Yuri A., Shutterstock
Are You Still Working?
If you’re working and can live off your income, you might have more flexibility. You could invest the $200K and let it grow while keeping your mortgage. But if you’re thinking about retiring soon, freeing yourself from a mortgage payment could make that transition smoother.
Don’t Forget Emergencies
Before you do anything, make sure you’ve got a solid emergency fund. Ideally, three to six months of living expenses. If that fund is thin, carve out a chunk of your inheritance to pad it. It’s not flashy, but it’s what keeps you stable if life throws a curveball.
Can You Do a Little of Both?
Here’s the thing—you don’t have to go all in on one option. You might pay off a chunk of your mortgage to reduce the balance, then invest the rest for retirement. That way, you lighten your debt and still build long-term savings.
Look at Interest vs. Return
Compare your mortgage rate to the average return on retirement investments. If your mortgage is at 3% and you could earn 6–8% in a retirement account, investing might make more sense mathematically. But remember—investments come with risk, and the market doesn’t guarantee anything.
Max Out Retirement Accounts
If you do invest, make sure you’re taking full advantage of catch-up contributions. At 58, you can put more into your 401(k) and IRA than younger folks. Max those out before throwing money into a regular brokerage account. It could mean big tax advantages now and later.
Inside Creative House, Shutterstock
Watch Out for Penalties
If you’re considering putting the money into a retirement account, be aware of withdrawal rules. If you might need the money before age 59½, you could face penalties on early withdrawals. A financial advisor can help you structure it safely.
Are You Supporting Others?
If you're helping kids, grandkids, or other family members, think about how this decision affects your ability to keep doing that. Paying off the house might reduce stress but leave you with less flexibility. Investing might help you grow your support cushion—but also comes with more uncertainty.
What’s Your Risk Tolerance?
If the idea of market ups and downs makes you anxious, paying off your mortgage might help you feel more stable. If you’re okay riding out some volatility for the chance of higher returns, investing could suit you better. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here.
Talk to a Fiduciary
Find a fee-only fiduciary financial advisor—someone legally required to act in your best interest. They can walk through your entire financial picture and help you make a plan that’s tailored to your life, not just general advice. It’s worth the one-time cost for peace of mind.
Jacob Wackerhausen, Getty Images
Think Long-Term Security
What gives you the most peace of mind at 70? Having zero housing costs? Or having a bigger nest egg that you can draw from? Try to picture both futures—and which one feels more stable. That might help guide your decision more than math alone.
It’s Okay to Take Time
You don’t have to decide tomorrow. Park the money in a high-yield savings account while you weigh your options. Just don’t let it sit for too long without a plan. Set a deadline (like 30–60 days) to decide your direction and move forward with confidence.
This Is a Good Problem
It might feel stressful now, but this is a great opportunity. You’re in a position to improve your future and lighten your financial load. Whether you invest, pay off your home, or do a little of both—you’re setting yourself up for more control and freedom.
You May Also Like:
My car insurance doubled but I'm locked into a long loan. How do I budget for this?
