More?
Being named executor can sound like an honor until the court forms, bank calls, bills and family questions begin. Suddenly, one child is doing months of work while everyone else appears to be waiting for a check. Does that extra burden justify receiving more from the estate?
The Job May Be Bigger Than It Looks
An executor may have to locate accounts, secure property, arrange appraisals, communicate with creditors, file tax returns and keep beneficiaries informed. Even a fairly ordinary estate can consume dozens of evenings and weekends. A complicated one can feel like taking on a second job.
Other Beneficiaries May Not See That Work
Siblings may notice when the house sells or their inheritance arrives, but not the hours spent sorting records, meeting lawyers and answering questions. That can understandably leave an executor wondering why everyone should receive the same amount when only one person handled the work.
There Are Actually Two Questions Here
The first question is whether the executor should receive compensation for administering the estate. The second is whether the executor should receive a larger share of the inheritance. Those may sound like the same question, but the law generally treats them very differently.
Executors Are Often Legally Entitled To Compensation
In many states, an executor has a legal right to be paid even when the will never mentions compensation. This is not simply a favor that the other beneficiaries must approve. State probate law may already entitle the executor to a fee for performing the required work.
Sometimes That Fee Is A Percentage
California bases ordinary compensation on the estate accounted for by the representative, while Florida uses the compensable probate estate and estate income. New York calculates commissions on money and property received and paid out. These formulas do not necessarily include every asset the mother owned.
But That Is Not The Rule Everywhere
Not every state gives executors a fixed percentage. Massachusetts, for example, provides reasonable compensation. Other states also consider the time involved, complexity of the estate, responsibilities assumed and results achieved. Detailed records become especially important when another beneficiary questions the eventual fee.
The Will Can Still Affect The Answer
A will may establish a particular fee, provide its own calculation or direct the executor to serve without compensation. However, that instruction is not always final. Depending on the state, the executor may be allowed to reject the provision or ask the probate court to authorize different compensation.
Being Named Is Not The Same As Being Appointed
A person named as executor in a will does not necessarily gain immediate authority over the estate. The person generally must accept the role and receive formal authorization from the probate court, often called letters testamentary, before controlling accounts or transferring estate property.
Compensation Is Not A Larger Inheritance
This is the most important distinction. An executor's fee is compensation for administering the estate. It is paid as an estate expense before the remaining property is distributed. A larger inheritance means receiving a greater portion of what remains under the terms of the will.
The Difference Changes The Math
Suppose two children are supposed to divide an estate equally, but one is the executor. After debts, expenses and lawful executor compensation are paid, the remaining estate is divided equally. The executor may receive more money overall, but the inheritance itself is still divided as directed.
LightField Studios, Shutterstock
An Executor Cannot Rewrite The Shares
If the will leaves equal shares to three children, the executor generally cannot decide that the shares should become 40%, 30% and 30%. The executor is responsible for carrying out the will, not creating a different distribution based on what now feels fair.
That Is True Even When The Workload Is Unequal
Performing all the administrative work does not normally give the executor authority to reduce another beneficiary's inheritance. Taking estate money outside the authorized compensation process could lead to objections, removal as executor or personal liability for the missing funds.
The Will May Already Leave The Executor More
A parent can intentionally leave children unequal inheritances in many circumstances. If the will gives the executor a larger share, the executor can generally receive that share while also administering the estate. Serving as both an executor and a beneficiary is extremely common.
The Fee Comes Out Of The Estate
Executor compensation is generally paid from estate assets, which means it reduces the amount ultimately available to beneficiaries. That does not make the fee improper. Legal fees, accounting bills, property expenses and other costs of administration also come out before the final inheritance is distributed.
The Executor May Not Need Family Permission
When compensation is authorized by state law or the will, other beneficiaries may not have the power to simply veto it. They may still challenge an excessive or improperly calculated fee, but disliking the idea of the executor being paid does not automatically eliminate the entitlement.
Court Approval May Still Be Required
The payment process varies. Florida allows ordinary statutory compensation to be paid without a separate court order, while other situations may require an accounting or court approval. An executor should confirm the local procedure before transferring any estate money personally.
Do Not Simply Write Yourself A Check
Even when compensation is clearly allowed, taking money too early can create trouble. Debts, taxes and other estate obligations may still be unknown. The executor should follow the required approval process and make sure the estate can afford the payment before collecting it.
Expenses Are Separate From The Fee
An executor should generally be reimbursed for legitimate estate expenses paid personally, such as filing costs, postage, necessary travel or property-maintenance bills. Reimbursement is not compensation or additional inheritance. However, every expense should be reasonable, documented and directly related to administering the estate.
Keep Every Receipt And Record
Executors should track expenses, hours worked, calls made and significant decisions. "The estate owes me several thousand dollars" is likely to start an argument. A dated record supported by receipts and statements makes both reimbursements and compensation much easier to explain.
The Fee Must Still Follow The Rules
Being an executor does not necessarily mean taking the largest imaginable payment. Statutory formulas must be calculated correctly, while reasonable compensation should match the work performed. Depending on state law, a court may reduce or deny compensation when an executor performs poorly or claims an unjustified amount.
Executor Fees Are Taxable
The IRS requires personal representatives to include executor fees in their gross income. A family member who is not regularly in the executor business will ordinarily report the payment differently from a professional executor, but the fee is still taxable federal income.
Inheritances Are Treated Differently
Property received as an inheritance generally is not included in federal taxable income merely because it was inherited. However, retirement-account withdrawals, income produced by inherited assets and gains from selling inherited property may be taxable. Some states also impose estate or inheritance taxes.
Caregiving Is A Different Issue
Perhaps the executor also spent years caring for the parent, attending appointments or covering household expenses. It may seem fair for that child to receive more, but those sacrifices do not normally allow the executor to change the will after the parent has passed away.
Money Owed By The Parent Must Be Proven
If the parent genuinely owed the executor money, that may be a valid debt of the estate rather than additional inheritance. But undocumented family arrangements are easily challenged. Receipts, written agreements, bank records and professional advice become especially important when the person making the claim controls the estate.
The Family May Agree To A Different Distribution
Adult beneficiaries can sometimes enter into a properly prepared family settlement or similar agreement changing how property is distributed. Whether that is permitted depends on state law and the estate's circumstances. It should be handled through an estate attorney, not an informal promise between siblings.
Giving Money Away Later Is Another Option
A beneficiary may receive what the will provides and later give some of it to another family member. However, that transfer could be treated as a gift and may create tax-reporting or financial consequences. Everyone should understand those consequences before moving the money.
Transparency Will Prevent Many Arguments
When an executor is also a beneficiary, personal payments naturally receive extra scrutiny. Sharing inventories, expense records, major decisions and accountings can stop ordinary transactions from looking suspicious. Secrecy is often what turns a reasonable executor's fee into a lasting family dispute.
Estate Money Must Remain Separate
Estate funds should be held in a properly titled estate account rather than mixed with the executor's personal money. Bills, reimbursements, compensation and beneficiary distributions should all be traceable. Good records protect the beneficiaries and an executor who has acted correctly.
Waiving The Fee Is Still An Option
Some family executors choose to waive compensation, especially when the estate is simple or they already receive a substantial inheritance. Others reasonably accept the fee because the work is extensive. The executor should understand the workload, family consequences and tax treatment before deciding.
So Is It Fair To Receive More
Yes, an executor may fairly and legally receive more money overall because many states provide compensation even when the will says nothing about it. But that payment is an executor's fee, not a self-awarded increase in the inheritance. The will still controls everyone's shares unless a valid agreement or court order changes them.
You Might Also Like:
