Congratulations, You Inherited A Second Job
Your parents trusted you enough to put you in charge of their estate. Now you are sorting paperwork, dealing with banks, tracking bills, answering questions, and possibly preparing a house for sale while your siblings wait for their inheritance. Then someone suggests that taking an executor fee would be “making money off Mom and Dad,” and suddenly an already difficult job becomes a family argument.
Yes, Executors Can Usually Be Paid
In the United States, serving as executor does not normally mean volunteering your time for free. State laws commonly provide some form of compensation for the person administering an estate, although the rules for calculating and approving that compensation vary dramatically. Being related to the deceased does not automatically erase that right.
But There Is No National Executor Rate
This is where well-meaning advice from friends can get confusing. One person may tell you executors receive a percentage of the estate, while someone else swears the fee is based on hours worked, and both could be describing the law where they live. Probate is largely governed by state law, so where the estate is being administered matters enormously.
Some States Use A Formula
California is an easy example of a state with a statutory formula for ordinary executor services. The percentage gets smaller as the probate estate becomes larger, and the court generally authorizes payment as part of the probate process. That means the executor is not simply inventing a number and writing themselves a check.
Carlos Javier Yuste Jiménez, Unsplash
Other States Use Commissions
New York does things a little differently. Executors there can be paid according to a formula set by state law, with the amount generally tied to the size of the estate they handle. The details can get complicated, but the important part is simple: getting paid for this work is not some sneaky move an executor invented.
And Some States Ask What Is Reasonable
Other states leave more room for judgment. In Massachusetts, for example, the law allows an executor to receive reasonable payment for the work they actually do. That means the difficulty of the job can matter, which is why comparing your fee with what a cousin received in another state may tell you very little.
The Will Gets A Say Too
Before discussing money with your siblings, read the will carefully. A will may contain instructions about compensation, and state law determines how those instructions interact with the executor's normal statutory rights. Never assume that the absence of a dollar amount means you automatically get nothing.
Being Named Is Not Quite The Same As Serving
Your parents may have named you executor in their will, but that does not necessarily mean you can immediately start moving money and selling property. In a probate case, the court generally has to officially put you in charge first. California, for example, uses a court process to appoint the person who will handle the estate.
You Are Doing More Than Signing Papers
An executor may need to locate property, protect assets, arrange appraisals, notify creditors, deal with claims, pay legitimate bills, handle taxes, keep records, and eventually distribute the remaining estate. Even relatively peaceful families can generate a surprising amount of administrative work. Calling all of that “just helping out” seriously understates the responsibility involved.
The House Can Become A Project By Itself
Suppose the estate includes your parents' home. Someone may need to maintain insurance, keep utilities running, secure the property, collect documents, arrange repairs, work with professionals, and possibly oversee a sale. Those jobs can quickly turn an executor role into months of calls, appointments, receipts, and decisions.
And You Are Responsible For Other People's Money
There is another reason executors can get paid: they are being trusted with somebody else's money and property. An executor has a legal duty to protect the estate, keep its money separate from their own, pay legitimate bills, and eventually get the remaining assets to the right people. That is considerably more responsibility than simply doing Mom and Dad one last favor.
Your Siblings Still Have A Legitimate Concern
Executor compensation usually comes out of estate assets. That means a fee can reduce what ultimately remains for beneficiaries, including the executor's siblings. They are allowed to care about the amount, even though caring about it does not automatically give them the power to declare that your labor must be free.
The Best Defense Is Transparency
Surprising everyone with a fee at the end is a great way to make a lawful payment look suspicious. Early in the process, explain that state law allows executor compensation and that you plan to follow the applicable rules rather than choose an arbitrary amount. Clear communication will not prevent every dispute, but secrecy practically invites one.
LightField Studios, Shutterstock
Keep Track Of What You Actually Do
If you are doing the work, keep a record of it. Write down major tasks, appointments, property problems, calls with professionals, and anything unusual that eats up your time. If a sibling later questions your fee, a simple record of what you actually did is much more convincing than trying to remember six months of headaches afterward.
https://kaboompics.com/, Pexels
Save Those Receipts Too
Executor compensation should not be confused with reimbursement for legitimate estate expenses that you personally advanced. Court filing charges, appraisal costs, publication expenses, and other administration costs may qualify for reimbursement depending on local rules. Keep receipts and separate those expenses from whatever compensation you ultimately request.
Do Not Treat The Estate Like An ATM
Even if you are clearly entitled to compensation, do not assume you can transfer estate money to yourself whenever you feel you have earned it. Procedures differ by state, and some jurisdictions require court authorization before compensation is paid. California's court rules, for example, prohibit personal representatives from paying themselves statutory or extraordinary compensation before an authorizing court order.
Web Stock Gallery, Shutterstock
Courts Can Question Excessive Fees
Being allowed to take a fee does not mean an executor can name any price they want. Courts can step in when compensation appears excessive, and Florida law, for example, allows a court to review an executor's compensation and potentially order excessive amounts returned. So your siblings can question a fee, but simply objecting to it does not automatically make the fee improper.
Difficult Estates Can Mean More Work
Some estates go far beyond the usual paperwork. Litigation, complicated tax matters, operating a deceased person's business, or other unusual problems can create substantial additional work, and some states expressly allow additional compensation for extraordinary services. Whether extra compensation is available and how it must be approved depends on the jurisdiction.
A Big Estate Is Not Always A Hard Estate
This is one reason executor fees can cause resentment. An estate containing one valuable house and a straightforward bank account may be worth more than an estate filled with modest but difficult assets, unpaid bills, family disputes, and tax complications. Depending on state law, the legal compensation formula may not perfectly mirror the amount of effort involved.
You Can Choose To Take Less
Being entitled to a fee does not necessarily mean you must take every dollar available. Some state laws expressly permit a personal representative to renounce all or part of the compensation, and California courts note that a representative can request less than the normal statutory amount. That gives families room for compromise when the full fee feels excessive relative to a simple estate.
You Can Also Choose To Take Nothing
Some executors waive compensation because they view the work as something they want to do for the family. That is a personal financial decision rather than proof that every family executor should work for free. If you waive compensation, do it deliberately after understanding what you are giving up rather than because someone guilted you at the kitchen table.
Taxes Can Change The Calculation
There is one catch that can make taking an executor fee less attractive. The IRS generally treats executor fees as taxable income, while money you receive simply because you inherited it is generally not federal taxable income to you. If you are both an executor and an heir, that difference is worth considering before deciding whether to take the fee or waive it.
Inheritances And Fees Are Not The Same Thing
If you are both executor and beneficiary, keep those two roles mentally separate. Your inheritance comes from your parents' estate plan, while executor compensation pays you for administering the estate. California probate guidance specifically warns that executor compensation is taxable income and notes that this can influence a beneficiary-executor's decision about whether to take a fee.
Do Not Hide A Fee To Keep The Peace
Quietly paying yourself and hoping nobody notices is usually worse than having an uncomfortable conversation upfront. Probate accounting and closing procedures can require disclosure of fees or commissions, and beneficiaries may have opportunities to question what happened to estate assets. A transparent fee that follows the law is much easier to defend than a mysterious transfer discovered months later.
A Professional Can Be Worth The Money
Being executor does not necessarily mean personally mastering every tax return, legal filing, appraisal, or complicated property issue. Personal representatives commonly work with attorneys, accountants, appraisers, and other specialists where appropriate, although rules governing which expenses the estate may bear vary. Getting qualified help can be particularly valuable when siblings are already threatening to fight over your decisions.
Talk About The Fee Before The Final Check
A sensible family conversation can sound surprisingly boring. Explain what the estate requires, what your state's compensation rule says, what you have actually been doing, and whether you intend to request the full permitted fee or something smaller. Turning the argument from “How could you charge us?” into “Here is how the law handles this job” can lower the temperature considerably.
Fair Does Not Always Mean Free
Your siblings may sincerely believe everyone should sacrifice equally after a parent's death, but the executor is not doing the same job as everyone else. If one child spends months handling the estate while the others simply receive distributions, reasonable compensation is not automatically greedy or disloyal. The system allows executor compensation precisely because administering an estate can involve substantial work and responsibility.
Follow The Rules And Drop The Guilt
So should executors get paid? In many U.S. estates, the law says they can, and the amount is determined by state law, the will, the work involved, and sometimes the probate court. Check the rules where the estate is being administered, document your work and expenses, disclose what you are requesting, consider the tax consequences, and then decide whether taking all, part, or none of the available compensation feels right for your situation.
You May Also Like:
