A small-town priest buys a £400 painting…and accidentally uncovers a masterpiece
Father Jamie MacLeod’s £400 antiques-shop painting hung quietly on a retreat-house wall for years. It looked like a simple old portrait—pleasant, a little mysterious, but nothing remarkable. Then one casual visit to Antiques Roadshow turned that quiet purchase into one of the show’s most extraordinary discoveries.
He thought it was just a £400 antiques-shop painting
Father MacLeod said the portrait “just had something about it,” even though nothing indicated a famous artist. No signature, no paperwork—just a compelling face. He bought it simply because he liked it, never imagining it held a centuries-old secret beneath the cloudy varnish.
Anthony van Dyck, Wikimedia Commons
The painting blended into the background—admired but overlooked
For more than a decade, the portrait hung quietly at Whaley Hall, his retreat house in Derbyshire. Guests sometimes commented on it, but no one suggested it might be valuable. It was the definition of a sleeper artwork—perfectly visible, yet completely unrecognized.
Jonathan Clitheroe , Wikimedia Commons
A simple Antiques Roadshow visit changes everything
When Antiques Roadshow filmed at Newstead Abbey in 2013, he brought the painting along out of curiosity. He expected a modest appraisal, nothing dramatic. But experts instantly paused, studying the brushwork with the kind of intensity that signals something unusual.
Darrendeans, Wikimedia Commons
Experts immediately sensed something different
The confident brushwork and strong modeling looked far more sophisticated than the typical 19th-century copies that often appear on the show. One expert later said the painting showed “too much quality to dismiss,” shifting it immediately from curiosity to a serious authentication candidate.
Philip Halling , Wikimedia Commons
Fiona Bruce steps in with a crucial hunch
Host Fiona Bruce examined the portrait and suggested Father MacLeod take it to art conservator Simon Gillespie. She later said, “It’s everyone’s dream to spot a hidden masterpiece…I’m thrilled my hunch paid off.” Her instincts became the catalyst for a major rediscovery.
Restoration uncovers a completely different painting
At Gillespie’s studio, layers of discolored varnish and extensive overpaint were removed. Beneath them, a vibrant, expressive face emerged. The studio described the transformation as uncovering “the true quality of the work”—a shift so dramatic it demanded expert re-evaluation.
SimonGillespieStudio, Wikimedia Commons
The moment the experts realized what it really was
After conservation, Van Dyck specialist Dr. Christopher Brown confirmed the portrait as an authentic Anthony van Dyck head study. This wasn’t a copy or workshop piece—it was the real thing. The discovery stunned both Roadshow staff and art historians.
Philip Halling , Wikimedia Commons
It matched a figure from a long-lost masterpiece
Experts identified the study as one of the heads from The Magistrates of Brussels, a large van Dyck composition destroyed during the 1695 bombardment of Brussels. Scholars had only engravings and a grisaille reference—until this surviving study surfaced.
Philip Halling , Wikimedia Commons
A rare fragment of a destroyed artwork
Because the original painting was lost centuries ago, this rediscovered study became a rare surviving fragment of the composition. One art historian described it as “a reappearing piece of a vanished work,” a link to a painting believed lost forever.
The valuation shocks everyone on set
Experts valued the painting at up to £400,000. Multiple outlets reported it as the most valuable painting ever identified on Antiques Roadshow to that point. The reveal left Father MacLeod visibly stunned—a moment that quickly went viral.
The priest reacts with humility and disbelief
He said, “I’m just completely shocked. It’s been an emotional experience and it’s such great news.” His reaction—more gratitude than excitement—became part of the charm of the discovery, grounding a historic art find in a quiet, human moment.
He planned to use the money for church bells
Rather than keep the windfall, Father MacLeod announced the sale would fund new church bells for Whaley Hall’s chapel. He said it was “wonderful that new church bells will hopefully be pealing out” to mark the WWI centenary—a poetic use for an unexpected treasure.
Christie’s prepares for a high-profile auction
The painting was cataloged for Christie’s in London with an estimate between £300,000 and £500,000. Collectors and museums were watching closely—a newly authenticated Van Dyck connected to a destroyed masterpiece is exceptionally rare.
Christies1766, Wikimedia Commons
But the auction delivers an unexpected twist
Despite widespread interest, the painting did not sell at the 2014 Christie’s auction. The art market can be unpredictable—timing and bidder presence matter. The lack of a hammer price didn’t diminish its historical importance or its authentication.
Portable Antiquities Scheme from London, England, Wikimedia Commons
Museums step in and give the painting a global stage
The work was later sold privately and subsequently loaned to major museums, including Antwerp’s Rubenshuis and New York’s Frick Collection. For a painting once found in a regional antiques shop, its rise into elite museum spaces was astonishing.
The discovery becomes an international headline
Media outlets around the world reported on the find. The Telegraph, ITV, BBC and others highlighted it as one of the greatest rediscoveries in the show’s history, turning Father MacLeod—briefly—into the unlikely face of an art-historical sensation.
Scholars celebrate a rare historical recovery
Van Dyck experts noted that preparatory studies for destroyed compositions are especially valuable. The painting helped fill a crucial gap in understanding The Magistrates of Brussels, enriching scholarship on Van Dyck’s portrait methods and workshop practice.
Anthony van Dyck, Wikimedia Commons
The find proves masterpieces still hide in plain sight
The story showed that remarkable works can still surface far from museums—sometimes in antiques shops, sometimes on living-room walls. Discoveries like this remind historians that significant works aren’t always where anyone expects them to be.
Antiques Roadshow calls it one of their greatest moments
The Roadshow team described the discovery as a highlight of the series. Fiona Bruce said she was “thrilled” and called it the kind of find “you hope for but never expect,” cementing it as a defining moment for the show.
Portable Antiquities Scheme from London, England, Wikimedia Commons
The antiques-shop angle becomes legendary
Experts and viewers alike fixated on the idea that a genuine Van Dyck had been sitting in a small local shop for £400. It instantly became one of those stories that fuels every bargain-hunter’s fantasy about uncovering a hidden masterpiece.
Philip Halling , Wikimedia Commons
Father MacLeod stays grounded despite the spotlight
He returned to his work running Whaley Hall, saying the experience “deepened my appreciation for art and its mysteries.” The sudden attention never changed him—it simply became a memorable chapter in an otherwise quiet life of service.
Anthony van Dyck, Wikimedia Commons
The rediscovery reshapes Van Dyck scholarship
Because the painting is tied to a destroyed composition, its authentication carries outsized importance. Every newly recognized Van Dyck study adds to the understanding of his technique, but this one—linked to a lost masterwork—holds special weight.
GoldenArtists, Wikimedia Commons
A £400 painting that became a cultural moment
The portrait’s journey—from antiques-shop purchase to Roadshow sensation to museum exhibitions—became a rare feel-good art story. It blended luck, expertise and history into a moment that resonated across the art world and beyond.
Sometimes extraordinary treasures really are hiding in plain sight
What began as a simple £400 purchase became a world-class rediscovery. The story is a reminder that even the most extraordinary treasures sometimes start in ordinary places—and that one curious decision can rewrite history.
Philip Halling , Wikimedia Commons
You Might Also Like:
