Wait—They Said What Now?
Imagine this: you're a new employee at the office when your boss casually suggests, “We already have a Jessica. Can we call you Jess 2?” Or worse, they ask you to change your name entirely because it’s “too confusing”. Sounds ridiculous, right? Unfortunately, it happens more often than you’d think. Whether it’s out of laziness, awkwardness, or misguided attempts at efficiency, some managers think it’s acceptable to ask—or even insist—that employees go by a different name.
So what do you do when it happens to you? Are you allowed to say no? And what are your rights if they won’t back off?
Is It Legal For A Boss To Rename You?
There’s no law that explicitly says your boss can’t call you a nickname. However, there are serious legal concerns if the issue crosses into harassment, discrimination, or if it interferes with your ability to do your job. In general, if your boss refuses to use your legal name, or insists on calling you something else despite your clear objections, it could become a legal issue—especially if it relates to your gender identity, ethnicity, religion, or another protected category.
Legal VS Preferred Name: What’s The Difference?
When it comes to understanding your rights, it’s important to know the difference between your legal name and your preferred name. Your legal name is the one listed on your government-issued documents like your driver’s license or passport. Your preferred name is the name you choose to go by in everyday life, which may be different from your legal name. This is common in situations involving nicknames, middle names, anglicized names, or chosen names for gender affirmation. Your legal name must often be used for payroll and formal documents, but your preferred name should be respected in workplace interactions.
When It’s Your Legal Name On The Line
If your boss refuses to let you use your legal name, or asks you not to use it, that’s a serious issue. It could create confusion in official records, misalignment with tax and employment documentation, and possibly even affect your ability to access benefits or provide proof of employment. Beyond the logistics, it also sends a message that your identity isn’t being acknowledged.
When It’s A Preferred Name Issue
If the name in question is your preferred name—especially if you’re transgender, nonbinary, or gender nonconforming—then the situation becomes even more sensitive. Employers are not legally required to use your preferred name in every single instance, but refusing to do so repeatedly and intentionally may constitute harassment under civil rights laws. If your boss is constantly misnaming you, or doing so with a dismissive or mocking tone, it could be considered a hostile work environment.
What US Federal Law Says
While there is no single federal law that specifically governs name usage in the workplace, broader anti-discrimination protections may apply. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination based on race, religion, sex, and national origin. In recent years, federal agencies like the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) have interpreted this to include gender identity and expression.
State Laws To The Rescue
Some states go even further than federal guidelines. States like California, New York, Oregon, and others have laws that protect workers’ rights to express their gender identity, which includes being addressed by their chosen name and pronouns. Employers in these states may be violating state law by refusing to respect people’s names—even if it hasn’t been legally changed yet.
What If It’s Not About Gender, Just “Too Many Jessicas”?
Let’s say this isn’t about gender at all and your boss just thinks it’s easier to avoid having two people with the same name in the office. While this may not fall under protected legal categories, it’s still worth pushing back on. Management’s job is to accommodate people—not force people to accommodate them. Having multiple employees with the same name isn’t exactly a new workplace phenomenon. There are better ways to handle it, such as using last initials or full names, rather than assigning someone a nickname they didn’t choose.
Check Your Employee Handbook
Before you take any formal action, take a look at your company’s employee handbook or code of conduct. Many organizations include sections on respect, inclusion, and identity. If the company claims to value diversity or employee dignity, you can use their own policies to support your case. If the handbook outlines how employees should be addressed or sets expectations for respectful communication, you’ve got a solid foundation to raise your concerns.
Talk To Your Boss First
While it may feel awkward, sometimes the best first step is a direct conversation. Explain how you feel in a calm, non-confrontational way. You might say something like, “I know there’s another Jessica on the team, but this is the name I go by and I’d really appreciate it if we could find a way to distinguish us without changing it”. A reasonable manager should respect that and work with you on a solution. If they don’t, it tells you a lot about how they handle bigger issues too.
Bring HR Into The Conversation
If a direct conversation doesn’t lead anywhere—or if your boss reacts negatively—it’s time to loop in Human Resources. HR departments are trained to navigate conflicts like these and are often the best resource for resolving name-related issues. Explain the situation clearly, mention how it makes you feel, and reference any applicable policies or protections. Framing it as an issue of workplace respect and inclusion can help move the conversation forward.
When It’s Time To Document Everything
If the situation escalates or becomes part of a pattern, start documenting each instance. Write down what happened, when, who was involved, and how you responded. This kind of paper trail can be important if you ever need to file a formal complaint or take legal action.
What If It’s A Trans Or Nonbinary Name Change?
For transgender and nonbinary employees, using the correct name is more than a matter of preference—it’s about safety, identity, and dignity. Repeatedly refusing to use a trans person’s chosen name has been recognized by courts and civil rights organizations as a form of discrimination. If your employer insists on using a deadname or refuses to update internal systems with one’s preferred name, there are legal grounds to challenge them under Title VII, especially if this causes emotional harm or impacts work.
When You Can File A Complaint
If you believe you’re experiencing name-based discrimination or harassment, and your company won’t address it internally, you can consider filing a complaint externally. Depending on your situation, you can file with your state’s labor board, your local civil rights office, or the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). Keep in mind that there are often deadlines—sometimes as short as 180 days—so it’s smart to act quickly if things get serious.
Union Members: Talk To Your Rep
If you're part of a union, your collective bargaining agreement may include protections related to dignity, harassment, or name use. Contact your union representative and explain the situation. Unions often have additional channels for conflict resolution and can advocate on your behalf in situations where management oversteps.
Alternative Solutions, Besides Changing Your Name
If your workplace really can’t tell the difference between you and another coworker, suggest alternatives that don’t involve changing your name entirely. This could include using initials in email signatures, adding a last initial or nickname if you’re okay with it, or agreeing to use full names in meetings.
Stephen Phillips - Hostreviews.co.uk, Unsplash
What If You Like The Nickname?
Of course, there’s no problem if you’re genuinely fine with using a nickname—whether it’s one you’ve always liked or a fun variation your team comes up with. The key point here is that it has to be your choice. If you embrace the new name and it doesn’t bother you, go for it. But no one—boss or otherwise—should impose it on you without your consent.
Respect Isn’t Confusing
The core issue here isn’t how many people share the same name at work. The real problem is when managers forget that employees are individuals, not interchangeable pieces on a spreadsheet. Respecting someone’s name isn’t confusing—it’s just a basic form of courtesy. A good boss knows that, and a good workplace reflects it.
Final Thoughts: You’re Not Overreacting
It might seem like a small thing to someone else, but if being renamed at work makes you feel uncomfortable, diminished, or disrespected, your feelings are completely valid. Names matter. They reflect who we are, how we show up in the world, and how we’re treated by others. You shouldn’t have to give yours up just to make life easier for someone else.
You May Also Like:
My boss demanded I name my baby after him if I wanted maternity leave. Can I sue?
