Rejecting A Raise For The Wrong Reason
You offered one of your strongest employees a well-earned promotion and a hefty raise to boot. But instead of celebrating, he hesitated and declined, saying that he didn’t want to be pushed into a higher tax bracket and end up earning less money overall with more responsibility. You’re now stuck trying to correct a financial misconception that he has in his head while also keeping a valuable worker motivated and engaged.
The Tax Bracket Fear
A lot of otherwise smart employees genuinely think that earning more money will cause the government to tax their entire income at a higher rate. This belief actually leads some workers to avoid overtime, bonuses, promotions, or even raises. It sounds logical on the surface, but this is a misunderstanding about how progressive income tax systems actually function.
How Progressive Tax Brackets Really Work
In the United States, federal income taxes operate on what is called a progressive system. This means income is taxed in layers. Each tax bracket applies only to the portion of income that falls within that bracket. When someone moves into a higher bracket, only the income above the threshold is taxed at that higher rate.
stevepb, CC0, Wikimedia Commons
You Never Take Home Less By Earning More
A common myth is that going up into a higher tax bracket will suddenly cause all of your income to now be taxed at that higher rate. But this isn’t how the system works. A raise always gives you more total take-home pay, even if the marginal rate on that additional income may be slightly higher.
An Example Makes It Clear
Suppose a worker earns just below the next tax threshold and receives a raise that pushes a portion of income into the next bracket. Only that additional slice is taxed at the new rate. The rest of the money remains taxed at the lower rate. Your overall income always increases after a raise.
Why Does This Myth Persist?
Tax withholding tables, paycheck deductions, and confusing, muddleheaded online comments fuel this rampant misunderstanding. Employees may see a larger tax deduction on a single paycheck after a raise and assume that they’re worse off. But without any context about the marginal rates and end-of-year tax reconciliation, it can seem like the system punishes success.
Start With A Calm Conversation
If your employee declines a raise simply because of the tax concerns, you can start with a private and respectful conversation. Make sure you don’t dismiss their worries outright. Ask what they really believe will happen and listen to them carefully. Often, simply explaining marginal tax brackets in plain language will overcome most resistance.
LinkedIn Sales Solutions, Unsplash
Show The Numbers Clearly
Sometimes verbal explanations aren’t enough. Walk through a simple calculation showing before-and-after income. Demonstrate how only the additional dollars are taxed at that higher rate that they’re worried about. Seeing the math on paper helps you to correct the deeply ingrained emotional assumptions that more money could somehow mean less income.
LinkedIn Sales Solutions, Unsplash
Address Withholding Confusion
Explain that payroll withholding is an estimate; it’s not a final tax bill. A raise might temporarily increase the amount that is withheld per paycheck, but the final taxes are always settled at filing time. That distinction helps employees understand why their take-home pay may look different in the short term.
Probe Other Hidden Concerns
Taxes might not be the only issue that the worker is worried about. Some employees use the bracket explanation as shorthand for broader worries, such as added responsibility, workload stress, or work-life balance changes. Make sure that the worker’s hesitation truly stems from tax misunderstanding before you start homing in solely on the financial side of things.
Consider Compensation Structure
If cash raises are still a sensitive issue, you could consider offering a mix of salary increase and performance bonuses, retirement contributions, or additional paid time off. Structuring total compensation in a thoughtful way can address both psychological and financial concerns while still rewarding performance and a higher level of responsibility.
Point Out Long Term Income Growth
Promotions aren’t just about immediate pay. They create long-term earning potential, leadership experience, and stronger career trajectories. Make sure you remind your employee that today’s raise compounds into future raises, larger retirement contributions, and stronger Social Security benefits over time.
Discuss Retirement Contributions
Higher income offers greater contributions to retirement accounts such as 401(k) plans or IRAs. Pre-tax retirement savings can also reduce taxable income, which may alleviate concerns about crossing bracket thresholds. This reframes the raise as a chance to implement some smarter financial planning.
Clarify Marginal Vs Effective Rates
Make sure your employee understands the difference between a marginal tax rate and an effective tax rate. The marginal rate applies only to the last portion of income earned. The effective rate represents the overall total of taxes paid divided by total income, which remains lower than the top bracket percentage.
Offer Educational Resources
Rather than relying solely on your own convoluted explanations, share some reputable educational materials about progressive taxation. Authoritative sources can reinforce what you’ve already outlined and give your employee the chance to research the matter on his own, building confidence in their understanding of how tax brackets actually function.
Don’t Force The Issue
Even if the math supports the raise, don’t pressure the employee into accepting it. Give them some time to think things over. Pushing too hard can make them feel cornered. Respectful patience maintains trust, especially if that’s a key contributor to your organization.
Involve A Financial Professional
If confusion still persists, you can suggest that the worker speak with a tax professional or financial planner. An independent expert can offer some neutral clarification outside of the work context. Sometimes hearing the same explanation from a third party removes all remaining doubts and reinforces confidence in accepting higher compensation.
Watch For Benefit Cliffs
While tax brackets don’t penalize higher income overall, there are certain government benefits or income-based programs that may phase out at specific thresholds. If applicable, you should review whether the raise affects any active health subsidies or credits. This is all a separate matter from marginal tax rates, but it is worth evaluating.
Always Protect Workplace Morale
If other employees see co-workers turning down promotions because of misguided notions about tax myths, it can spread similar fears across the whole team. Addressing misconceptions early helps you maintain a healthy understanding of compensation and prevents an undercurrent of confusion from spreading and undermining company growth opportunities.
Reframe The Raise As An Opportunity
Instead of focusing only on the taxation side of things, try to frame the promotion around career advancement, skill development, and leadership experience. Financial growth is only one component of a broader professional path. When employees see the complete picture, the tax concerns typically shrink in importance.
From Misunderstanding To Education
Situations like this aren’t setbacks but teaching moments. If you calmly address the tax bracket worries and misconceptions, you strengthen the financial literacy of your team. The result might be acceptance of the raise, but greater long-term confidence in making informed money decisions, and a more effective team. Which is just what you wanted!
Muhammad Faiz Zulkeflee, Unsplash
You May Also Like:
