Is That “Minor” Water Issue Really No Big Deal — Or A Legal Time Bomb?
You’re about to list your house. Your realtor casually says a small past leak isn’t worth mentioning. Your friend says hiding water problems is how lawsuits start. So is this harmless oversharing… or something that could come back to haunt you?
First, What Counts As A “Minor” Water Issue?
Water issues range from a one-time plumbing drip to recurring basement flooding. A tiny leak under a sink that was fixed years ago isn’t the same as foundation seepage. The problem? Sellers don’t always define “minor” the same way buyers — or courts — do.
Tony Webster, Wikimedia Commons
Why A Realtor Might Downplay It
In competitive markets, sellers want clean listings. Fewer disclosed issues can make a property feel more attractive. Some agents believe that repaired, insignificant issues don’t need emphasis if they’re fully resolved.
But Disclosure Laws Are Serious
Most states require sellers to disclose known material defects. A “material defect” is anything that could affect the home’s value or desirability. Water intrusion often qualifies — especially if it’s recurring, structural, or tied to mold risk.
The Key Word: Known
If you know about a problem and fail to disclose it, that’s where legal trouble starts. Courts care less about whether the issue was huge and more about whether you intentionally withheld information.
Why Water Is Different
Water damage isn’t just cosmetic. It can lead to mold, wood rot, electrical issues, and structural weakening. Even small leaks can signal bigger underlying problems. Buyers — and their inspectors — take water seriously.
“But It Was Fixed”
This is where many sellers feel safe. If the leak was repaired professionally and hasn’t returned, disclosure might simply involve explaining what happened and how it was resolved. Transparency often reduces suspicion.
What Happens If You Don’t Disclose?
If the buyer discovers post-sale water damage tied to a known issue you didn’t reveal, they could pursue legal action. Claims often fall under misrepresentation or failure to disclose material defects.
Lawsuits Aren’t Just TV Drama
Real estate disclosure lawsuits are common enough to keep attorneys busy. Even if you ultimately win, defending a claim costs time, stress, and money. Settlements can reach thousands — sometimes much more.
What Your Friend Is Worried About
Your friend is thinking worst-case scenario: the buyer finds mold behind drywall months later and traces it back to an issue you knew about. At that point, “minor” won’t matter much.
Does Every State Work The Same Way?
No. Disclosure requirements vary by state. Some states use strict property condition disclosure forms. Others follow “buyer beware” principles — but even there, intentional concealment can still trigger liability.
Can An Inspection Protect You?
A buyer’s inspection helps, but it doesn’t eliminate your responsibility. If you knowingly hide something, the fact that an inspector missed it won’t automatically protect you.
What About Realtor Advice?
Realtors aren’t attorneys. While most aim to protect clients, legal interpretation of disclosure laws is ultimately a legal matter. When in doubt, a real estate attorney provides more reliable guidance than casual advice.
The Cost Of Over-Disclosing
Here’s the upside: over-disclosing rarely leads to legal problems. It might spark a buyer question or negotiation, but it reduces the risk of future claims.
The Cost Of Under-Disclosing
Under-disclosing, on the other hand, can lead to rescinded deals, repair demands, escrow disputes, or post-closing litigation. Even a “small” issue can snowball legally.
Intent Matters
If you genuinely didn’t know about an issue, that’s different from actively hiding it. Courts look closely at intent. Emails, repair invoices, and contractor reports can all become evidence.
How Buyers View Transparency
Buyers often appreciate honesty. Disclosing a repaired leak with documentation can actually build trust. Hiding it and having it discovered later destroys trust instantly.
So… Who’s Telling The Truth?
Your realtor may be thinking strategically about market appeal. Your friend is thinking about liability. When it comes to legal exposure, your friend’s concern carries real weight.
The Bottom Line
A “minor” water issue might feel insignificant — until it becomes a major dispute. Disclosure protects you more than it hurts you. In most cases, honesty isn’t just ethical — it’s legally safer.
You May Also Like:
