An Unexpected Shock
You trusted your financial advisor to do what you instructed him to, but instead, he sold a block of shares against your wishes. When the advisor caught the mistake, he compounded the error by repurchasing the shares at a 20% loss. Now you may be wondering whether to accept the loss, push back legally, or subject your entire financial strategy to a rethink.
Clarify The Extent Of The Mistake
Start by figuring out what actually happened. Was it an accidental misclick, a miscommunication of your instructions, or sheer negligence? Request trade records and written communications to get to determine if it’s a minor blunder, a regulatory violation, or grounds for disciplinary action. Get documentation before deciding anything.
Go Over Your Account Agreement
Most advisory relationships have client agreements outling responsibilities, error-handling policies, and liability. Review the agreement in detail. Some firms disclaim responsibility for “trading errors”; others will reimburse certain mistakes. Knowing the agreement inside out will help you know if your contractual rights include recovery of lost value.
Get An Explanation In Writing
Ask your advisor or their firm to give you a written account of what happened and why; and what they did to rectify the situation. An explanation on record will bring greater accountability and keep you from being brushed off with vague excuses. A professional advisor should be willing to explain clearly and transparently without getting defensive.
Demand To Know Company Policies
Most broker-dealers and advisory firms have clear policies for handling trade errors. These could include reimbursement, internal insurance coverage, or escalation procedures. Get these policies in writing. Knowing how the firm handles similar instances helps you figure out if they’re following standard procedures or pushing the whole loss onto you.
Know The Regulatory Implications
Advisors are held to fiduciary or suitability standards depending on licensing. Selling shares against your express wishes could be a breach of fiduciary duty. If you suspect negligence or misconduct, it could fall under the purview of FINRA (Financial Industry Regulatory Authority), the SEC (Securities Exchange Commission), or your state’s securities regulator. Even if it was unintentional, regulators expect care and compliance.
Run The Numbers
While a 20% loss is frustrating, total up its actual dollar impact. Is it a few hundred, a few thousand, or a lot more? Does repurchase have long-term recovery potential if the stock rebounds? Sometimes a short-term paper loss won’t devastate your portfolio if the asset keeps gaining ground. Document the loss value anyway; it’ll give you leverage in possible negotiations.
Talk Straight To Management
If your advisor won’t fix the issue, go up the chain to the branch manager or compliance officer. Firms like to settle complaints internally before they become regulatory matters. By escalating the matter, you apply pressure for a fair resolution, whether that involves possible reimbursement or credits to your account. As mentioned above keep a copy on file of every conversation.
Filing A Complaint
If you feel like things aren’t being properly handled, file a formal complaint with FINRA or the SEC. Filing triggers compliance reviews and shows the firm that you mean business. Sometimes just the act of filing a complaint will give the necessary motivation for firms to settle issues quickly to avoid scrutiny or harming the company’s reputation.
Know Your Legal Options
For larger losses, you might be able to go through arbitration or litigation. Most brokerage agreements require binding FINRA arbitration instead of court. This process can be a complicated business, but consulting a securities attorney will quickly help you get a sense of whether or not legal measures are worth your while. Don’t dive into legal action lightly: though it may be necessary sometimes, you can end up paying a steep price.
Take A Long Hard Look At Your Advisor Relationship
Even if the firm reimburses you, this miscue reveals some cracks in the foundation of trust that should underpin every client-advisor relationship. Ask yourself if you still feel comfortable relying on them for sound financial advice. If communication was unclear or negligence happened, maybe you need to find an advisor whose professionalism and attentiveness is more in line with what you need.
Learn From The Mistake
Use this as a reminder to set clear boundaries. Always document instructions in writing, double-check confirmations, and review your account activity regularly. Trust is important, but strict oversight will protect you from errors. Your own vigilance can stop small mistakes from turning into expensive ones that interfere with your goals. With this in mind, let’s review the key points of what to do, and what not to do when an advisor screws up.
Do Request Documentation Of The Mistake
Insist on written records of the trade, including time stamps and order confirmations. Documentation sets a base level of accountability and gives your case backing if you seek reimbursement or arbitration at a later date.
Do Escalate To Management Quickly
If your advisor isn’t trying to fix the issue, talk to the firm’s branch manager or compliance department. This should provide the necessary urgency so that your complaint gets proper attention and review.
Photo By: Kaboompics.com, Pexels
Do Seek Regulatory Guidance
If internal escalation fails, reach out to FINRA, the SEC, or your state securities regulator. These agencies have complaint channels and the means to exert pressure on firms to act responsibly.
Do Consult A Securities Attorney
For larger losses, legal counsel will help you understand your rights and options. An attorney will know whether you have grounds to pursue arbitration or negotiate a fair settlement with the firm.
Photo By: Kaboompics.com, Pexels
Don’t Assume You Have To Eat The Loss
Advisory mistakes shouldn’t have to fall on you. Firms often have error-handling policies. Don’t resign yourself to the notion that you have no recourse without a thorough review of the facts.
Don’t Wait Too Long
Regulatory and legal complaints usually have strict timelines. Moving quickly will keep your options open. Delays erode your position or can entirely do away with your ability to recover damages.
Don’t Let The Trust Factor Slide
Even if you do get reimbursed, broken trust can be hard to repair. Don’t be afraid to go with your gut on this one; if this advisor feels careless, look around for an advisor who puts top priority on diligence and communication.
Don’t Forget The Big Picture For Your Portfolio
A loss like this may sting, but even so, try to put it in the context of your overall portfolio. Try not to make an emotional buying or selling decision. Instead, look at whether your long-term financial strategy is still viable.
You May Also Like:
Warren Buffett's Easy Trick For Successful Investing