Toys Worth Real Money
Stuffed with plastic pellets and given adorable names and birthdays, Beanie Babies, created by Ty Inc, became a 90s craze that faded fast, yet certain ones have held surprising value decades after the original hype disappeared.
Matthew Fearn - PA Images, Getty Images, Modified
Princess The Bear: $10,000
Made in tribute to Princess Diana, this purple bear features a delicate rose emblem stitched onto its chest, adding to its emotional appeal. What really makes it stand out are the specific tags and poem details found only on authentic versions, which collectors still seek out today.
Britannia The Bear: $10,000
Ty released Britannia exclusively in the UK, which meant American collectors never had a fair shot at snagging one in stores. Because her design proudly showcases British national symbols, demand soared quickly. That limited availability sent her value across the pond—and into five figures.
Claude The Crab: $9,000
With a shell bursting in tie-dye colors, Claude quickly became one of Ty’s most eye-catching designs. Since early versions came with fewer tag variations, authentic ones are easier to spot. His short run didn’t last long, but those bold colors made him unforgettable.
Halo The Bear: $7,500
Halo arrived with soft white fabric, delicate angel wings, and a halo perched above its head, instantly setting it apart. While first editions skipped the poem changes found on newer tags, collectors now focus on fabric quality, which makes or breaks its value.
Frazer Harrison/KA, Getty Images
Gobbles The Turkey: $7,000
Ty released Gobbles as a festive addition, but his early retirement left only a limited flock behind. Because condition plays such a big role in pricing, clean versions are tough to come by. Each fall, collectors race to track down this holiday favorite.
Raymond Kasprzak, Shutterstock
Snort The Red Bull: $6,000
Snort’s bright red body gave it an edge right from the start, but Ty didn’t keep that version around for long. The switch to a brown design made color the biggest factor in value, and that bold original look still tops collector wishlists.
Screenshot from Beanie Mania, HBO Max (2021)
Peace Bear: $5,000
Peace Bear stood out instantly thanks to its tie-dye fabric, which made every one of them completely unique. Today, only the earliest runs carry the kind of value collectors chase, after it gained popularity as part of Ty’s 1990s “peace” collection.
Spangle The Bear: $4,000
Ty gave Spangle the full patriotic treatment—stars, stripes, and standout stitching that set early versions apart. That launch helped kick off an entire line of red, white, and blue bears, though only the first release with distinct fabric holds serious value.
Screenshot from Beanie Mania, HBO Max (2021)
Pinchers The Lobster: $3,500
What made Pinchers famous wasn’t its claws; it was a tag typo. Since the mistake got fixed in future runs, the flawed originals became one of the most studied Beanie slip-ups. Early versions featured a misspelled “PVC,” which sparked collector interest quickly.
Employee The Bear: $3,000
Unlike most Beanies, this one never sat on store shelves. That insider-only status turned it into a rare glimpse behind the curtain of the company. Ty gave it exclusively to employees, each with unique names and styling that made it stand out.
Dylanhatfield.com, Shutterstock
Mystic The Unicorn (Tan Horn): $2,700
Mystic’s early tan horn helped it stand apart from the crowd long before the gold-horn version appeared. Unicorns already draw attention, but this version earned an extra layer of rarity. The fabric also shifted between runs, making texture a helpful clue.
Johny Kristensen, Shutterstock
Peanut The Royal Blue Elephant: $2,500
Ty didn’t keep Peanut’s original royal blue version around for long, swapping it out for a lighter shade soon after release. Because production was so brief, the 1995 tush tag is key. Many owners also had no idea they were holding a rare toy.
Weenie The Dachshund: $2,500
With his long ears and loyal look, Weenie became an early favorite—but his time on shelves didn’t last. Ty retired him quickly, making mint versions hard to come by. That early fan base helped cement his status among valued Beanies.
Visit Roemvanitch, Shutterstock
#1 Bear: $2,500
You couldn’t buy this one, even if you tried. Ty made #1 Bear exclusively for internal promotions, so very few ever left the company's hands. Because it reflects the brand’s early identity, it’s one of the most elusive Beanies collectors still chase.
Iggy The Iguana: $2,000
No Beanie stirred up more tag confusion than Iggy. He came in a whirlwind of fabric colors, patterns, and errors—sometimes all at once. Rare versions paired with the right tags gave Iggy a chaotic charm that collectors couldn’t resist.
The End Bear: $2,000
While most Beanies marked beginnings, this one closed the chapter. The End Bear came in black with multicolor accents and marked the end of Ty’s original run. Limited production kept numbers low, which gave this farewell release lasting collector appeal.
Pouch The Kangaroo: $2,000
Before the Beanie craze took off, Pouch quietly entered the lineup with a stitched-in baby kangaroo. Early releases are now harder to find, especially with both tags intact. That attention to detail helped Pouch hop into long-term collector circles.
Nana The Monkey: $4,000
Simplicity worked in Nana’s favor. With a basic brown body and no flashy extras, she still became rare thanks to an early retirement. While updated monkeys came along later, it’s those original tags that give Nana lasting value among Beanie hunters.
Billy F Blume Jr, Shutterstock
Millennium Bear: $1,800
To mark the year 2000, Ty released Millennium Bear with shiny metallic threads woven into its fabric. Early production versions are worth more today, partly because many millennials held onto them unopened—treating each one like a fuzzy little time capsule of the era.
Star Tribune via Getty Images, Getty Images
Humphrey The Camel: $1,200
Humphrey walked into Beanie Baby history as one of the original nine released in 1993. His early versions were made in small numbers, so condition really matters. When the swing tag is still attached, this camel carries serious collector value.
Libearty The Bear: $1,200
Designed with a torch and patriotic colors, Libearty proudly joined Ty’s American-themed lineup. While later mass-produced versions became common, the early releases had clear design differences. That uniqueness helped it earn a lasting place among historically significant and collectible Beanies.
Screenshot from Beanie Mania, HBO Max (2021)
Patti The Platypus: $500–$1,000
Patti came in swinging with bold colors, including rare tan and purple versions that started it all. Later color releases were easier to find, which spread out her value. Still, many consider Patti the original queen of color-based Beanie buzz.
Screenshot from Beanie Mania, HBO Max (2021)
Chilly The Bear: $800
Wrapped in winter charm and soft seasonal colors, Chilly made his debut as a holiday-themed release. A short production run made him hard to find in stores. Now, he tends to pop up again when holiday nostalgia hits collectors hardest.
Flutter The Butterfly (Yellow Wings): $198–$500
The earliest version of Flutter came with yellow wings, making it a standout before other color variations arrived. Ty didn’t keep that version in production for long, and today, wing color remains the biggest clue for spotting this short-lived release.
Happy The Hippo: $275
While hippos weren’t rare in Ty’s world, Happy had something the others didn’t—early buzz. Slight color shifts across releases give certain versions an edge. Additionally, the earliest ones bring in higher prices, especially among collectors who’ve tracked every mold variation.
