Being Family Does Not Mean Working For Free
It can feel strange when your sister asks to be paid for settling your mom’s estate, especially if the paperwork looks straightforward. But executors are fiduciaries who take responsibility for gathering property, handling debts and taxes, maintaining records, and ultimately distributing assets. Compensation for doing that work is common and, depending on state law and the will, may be expressly authorized.
Prostock-studio, Shutterstock Images
Start With Your Mom’s Will
Before deciding whether your sister is asking too much, read the will. A will can specify how an executor will be compensated, and those instructions can matter more than what family members consider fair. State rules become especially important when the document says nothing about compensation.
Executor Fees Are Not One-Size-Fits-All
There is no single nationwide executor fee. States take very different approaches, ranging from percentage-based commissions to compensation that a probate court considers reasonable. That means a perfectly ordinary fee in one state could be calculated completely differently across the border.
Srdjan Randjelovic, Shutterstock
California Uses A Percentage Formula
California provides statutory compensation for ordinary executor services. The schedule starts at 4% of the first $100,000 of the estate accounted for, 3% of the next $100,000, and 2% of the next $800,000, with progressively lower percentages for larger amounts.
https://kaboompics.com/, Pexels
That Can Produce A Surprisingly Large Number
Under California’s formula, an estate valued at $500,000 can generate $13,000 in ordinary statutory compensation: $4,000 on the first $100,000, $3,000 on the second $100,000, and $6,000 on the remaining $300,000. The amount can therefore seem substantial even when administration is relatively uncomplicated.
New York Has Its Own Commission Schedule
New York also calculates executor commissions using statutory percentages. Its schedule begins at 5% on the first $100,000, then drops to 4% on the next $200,000 and 3% on the next $700,000, followed by lower rates at higher levels.
THICHA SATAPITANON, Shutterstock
Florida Starts At 3%
Florida law presumes a commission of 3% of the first $1 million of the compensable estate to be reasonable for ordinary services in formal administration. The percentage declines as the estate grows beyond $1 million.
Centre for Ageing Better, Pexels
Texas Calculates Things Differently
Texas generally allows a qualifying executor or administrator a 5% commission on amounts actually received or paid out in cash while administering an estate, subject to statutory exclusions and an overall limit. This illustrates why simply multiplying the estate’s headline value by a percentage can give you the wrong answer.
Some States Focus On What Is Reasonable
Washington takes another approach. When compensation is not provided by the will, its statute allows compensation that the court considers just and reasonable. The court may also reduce or deny compensation if the personal representative fails to properly perform the job.
A Simple Estate Still Requires Real Work
An executor generally has to identify and secure estate property, understand the will, deal with bills, maintain records, address tax matters, and distribute property correctly. Even when everyone gets along, those responsibilities do not disappear.
Someone Has To Inventory Everything
Executors may have to locate bank accounts, securities, vehicles, real estate, valuables, and other property. California, for example, requires a personal representative in formal probate to prepare an inventory and appraisal of estate assets.
Someone Has To Deal With Creditors
Estate administration also involves identifying legitimate debts and administration expenses. Depending on state procedure, creditors may need formal notice and an opportunity to present claims before beneficiaries receive their final distributions.
Taxes Can Add Another Layer
The executor may have tax responsibilities beyond your mom’s final individual income tax return. Estates can have their own income and filing obligations during administration, and circumstances can require additional federal or state filings.
Your Sister Is Taking On Personal Responsibility
An executor is not merely the relative who writes the checks. Fiduciaries can potentially face personal liability when they mishandle estate property, make improper distributions, fail to protect assets, or neglect required tax obligations.
She Has To Keep Estate Money Separate
Estate funds generally should not become part of an executor’s personal finances. Proper administration involves maintaining estate accounts and records so transactions can be documented and beneficiaries can see what happened to the property.
Reimbursement Is Different From Compensation
Do not confuse an executor fee with repayment of estate expenses. An executor might personally advance filing fees or other legitimate administration costs and later receive reimbursement. Compensation, by contrast, pays the executor for performing the job.
Lawyers Are A Separate Expense
Hiring an attorney does not necessarily eliminate executor compensation. An attorney may handle probate filings and specialized advice while the executor continues performing administrative duties. Whether both fees are allowed, and in what amounts, depends on applicable law and the circumstances.
Extraordinary Work Can Cost More
Some states permit additional compensation when an executor performs services beyond ordinary administration. Florida specifically identifies examples including selling property, handling litigation, dealing with tax proceedings, operating the decedent’s business, and handling protected homestead issues.
But Your Sister Cannot Simply Invent A Number
Being executor does not give someone unlimited authority to charge whatever feels appropriate. The amount must comply with the will and applicable state law, and court supervision may be available when compensation is disputed.
Ask How She Calculated The Fee
Instead of beginning with whether the number feels high, ask where it came from. Your sister should be able to explain whether she is relying on a statutory commission, an hourly calculation, language in the will, or another method permitted under your state’s rules.
Ask What Assets The Calculation Includes
This can matter enormously. Executor compensation formulas do not necessarily apply identically to every asset associated with the person who passed. State statutes define which property or transactions count toward the compensation calculation.
Probate Assets Matter
Property passing through probate is not necessarily the same thing as everything your mother owned or controlled. Ownership arrangements and beneficiary designations can affect how property transfers, so you need to know what is actually part of the administered estate before evaluating a fee.
https://kaboompics.com/, Pexels
Keep The Conversation About Numbers
A productive comparison is the proposed fee against the governing statute, will, estate value, work performed, and any court requirements. Comparing it solely with what another relative would have charged is much less useful because family members sometimes voluntarily waive compensation.
Waiving A Fee Is A Choice
The American Bar Association notes that family fiduciaries often waive compensation, but that does not mean they are automatically required to do so. Someone considering a waiver should understand the responsibilities involved before deciding to work without compensation.
There Is A Tax Catch For Your Sister
Executor compensation generally counts as taxable income to the person receiving it for federal income-tax purposes. The IRS specifically identifies executor, administrator, and personal-representative fees as compensation that must generally be included in gross income.
An Inheritance Is Different From A Fee
That tax treatment can make the distinction important when your sister is also an heir. Her executor compensation is payment for services, while property she receives as a beneficiary is a separate matter with different federal income-tax rules.
Courts Can Review Disputed Compensation
State procedures can provide ways to challenge excessive compensation. Florida, for example, expressly authorizes courts to review the reasonableness of personal-representative compensation and can require a person who received excessive compensation to refund the estate.
So Is Your Sister Asking Too Much?
The fact that your mom’s estate seems simple does not, by itself, make an executor fee excessive. Check the will, identify the governing state, determine exactly how your sister calculated the amount, and compare it with that state’s compensation rules. If the numbers still do not line up, an estate or probate attorney can evaluate the proposed fee before the estate is finally distributed.
You May Also Like:
