A Brother Backs Out
You and your siblings inherited your parents’ house and agreed to sell it together. You listed it with a realtor, and after multiple offers above asking, one prospective buyer emerged. But just a few days before close, one of your brothers changed his mind despite having signed the listing agreement. Since the realtor has done his job, he’s now demanding a commission, leaving the rest of you to sort through messy legal and financial questions.
Miljan Zivkovic, AdobeStock; Factinate
Why A Realtor Still Wants Commission
Even if the sale didn’t close, the realtor may be owed a commission if the listing contract said they earned it once they brought an offer meeting the terms. That contract functions like a binding agreement. Unless the contract states otherwise, you might be responsible for that fee. Carefully review the listing agreement.
You Can’t Close Without All Owners Agreeing
In most jurisdictions, if multiple people own a house as tenants in common, you can’t finalize a sale unless all co-owners consent. Each co-owner has their own undivided interest, and any one individual holdout can block a sale. That’s most likely what happened when your brother refused to proceed.
Don’t Rush To Pay Before Checking Rights
Before you write a check to the realtor, make absolutely certain whether or not your listing contract actually triggers the fee in this kind of scenario. Some contracts dictate that payment is only to me made upon closing. Others say payment is due upon presenting an acceptable offer. The details of your specific agreement will matter.
Consider Talking To A Real Estate Attorney
Because inheritance and co-ownership issues intersect with contract law, a qualified real estate or estate attorney can help interpret your obligations and rights. They can clarify whether you may owe the commission only if a sale closes or if the holdout sibling may be financially responsible instead.
Understand Your Right To Force A Sale
If you and the other owners genuinely want to sell but one owner refuses, many jurisdictions allow a partition action, which is a legal process to force either a sale or a division of the property. This action can resolve a deadlock when voluntary agreement is impossible.
A Partition Sale Could Resolve The Deadlock
A partition sale is typically a court-ordered sale of the property. After the property is sold, the proceeds are divided among the owners according to their shares. This legal remedy exists to prevent owners from being forced into indefinite co-ownership when they want out.
Timing Matters In Legal Actions
Legal remedies take time and money. If you wait too long to pursue action, strong offers may expire and carrying costs such as taxes, insurance, and maintenance may continue. Acting promptly allows you to preserve value and avoid additional financial loss.
You Can Also Sue The Holdout Sibling
In addition to pursuing a partition, you may have grounds to seek damages from the sibling who reneged, particularly if their refusal directly caused financial harm such as a lost sale or commission dispute. An attorney can advise whether this approach makes financial sense.
Buying Out The Hesitant Owner Is An Option
If the sibling who backed out wants to keep the property, one alternative is for the other brothers to buy him out at a mutually agreed valuation. This approach can unclog the stalemate while keeping family relationships intact and avoiding court.
Probate And Executors Can Affect The Process
If the house is still tied to an estate proceeding, the executor may have certain powers related to sale of the home. Probate requirements can slow or complicate transactions, so it’s important to have a good understanding of that structure before taking any further steps.
Emotions Can Complicate Family Sales
You’re dealing with far more here than just laws and contracts. Family history and emotion are often wrapped up with inherited property decisions. While it’s natural to be frustrated with the situation, staying focused on the financial and legal realities can help you avoid getting caught up in a spiral of escalating costs.
A Realtor’s Commission Is Often Negotiable
Even when a contract seems to have clear terms, real estate commissions can sometimes be negotiated, especially if the deal fell through for reasons beyond the agent’s control. Open communication may result in a reduced fee rather than a drawn-out dispute.
Keep Documentation Of All Agreements
Preserve all emails, listing agreements, signed offers, and written communications. Detailed records help if mediation or court is imminent and it also demonstrates your good-faith effort to complete the sale.
Mediation Could Save Time And Money
Mediation offers a structured setting for resolving disagreements without resorting to full litigation. A neutral third party can help you and your sibling reach a compromise, protecting more of the inheritance from legal costs.
Explore Tax And Financial Impacts
Inherited property sales can have major tax consequences, especially if the property has appreciated since the date of death. A consultation with a tax professional ensures you understand capital gains implications before coming to a resolution.
Title And Ownership Structure Matters
Whether you own the property as tenants in common or under another ownership structure affects your legal remedies and responsibilities. A thorough review of the deed clarifies exactly how decisions must be made among co-owners.
Think Ahead To Future Estate Planning
This situation goes to show how unclear estate instructions can create family conflict. Clear directives within a will or trust can prevent similar gridlock-type situations like these for future generations.
A Holdout May Not Be Able To Block A Partition Sale
In most areas, one co-owner can’t permanently prevent a sale if other owners go after a lawful partition action. The legal system generally protects each owner’s right to exit shared ownership.
Your Best Next Step: Professional Advice
Before you make any financial commitments or initiate litigation, seek advice from both a real estate attorney and a tax professional. Coordinated professional guidance will help you protect your share of the inheritance and move forward strategically.
You May Also Like:
